Tim Blake Nelson
(Marshall Applewhite)
Vera Farmiga
(Bonnie Nettles)
Simon Rex
(David)
Michael C. Hall
Grace Caroline Currey
(Michelle)
Jim Parsons
(Warren)
Matthew Glave
William Mapother
(Reverend Applewhite)
J.B. Yowell
Kelly Lynn Reiter
(Lee)
Danielle Vasinova
(Louise Applewhite)
Blake Robbins
(Deputy Willis)
Jana Gallagher
Paten Hughes
(Karen)
Molly Robbins
Jill Winternitz
(Holly)
Layne Lazor
(Penny)
Geoffrey Arend
(Kevin)
Don McManus
Kaitlyn Kemp
(Terrie)
Kim DeLonghi
(Ann)
Randolph Parks
(Facody)
Dominick LaRuffa Jr.
(Tom Ramirez)