Kyle Secor
(Caleb Solar)
Alan Ruck
(Kenneth Thith)
Jim Gaffigan
(Ivy Vaughn)
Tracy Hutson
(Nicola McCoy)
Graeme Malcolm
(Neville Asquith)
David Moscow
(Isaac Melnick)
Laraine Newman
(Elizabeth Wilberforce)
Ethan Phillips
(Terry Festinger)
David Warshofsky
(Doug)
Judd Nelson
(Rufus the Buck-Toothed Sluggard)
William Fichtner
(Prince Victor)
Jay O. Sanders
(Bo Tatum)
Debbie Matenopoulos
(Lisa Swayzak)
Mark Shanahan
(Newscaster)
Zach Braff
(Dean)
Judah Friedlander
(Wrestling Fan)
Steve Gormley
(Mitch Hamm)
Kristen Eykel
(Knights of Yahweh Girl #1)
Carolyn Cantor
(Knights of Yahweh Girl #2)
Chris Crockett
(Townie)