Joshua Malina
(Gary Bloomfield)
Rachelle Lefevre
(Rabbi Dani)
Carlos Ponce
(Father Diaz)
Hank Greenspan
(Ethan Bloomfield)
Caroline Valencia
(Camille)
Mindy Sterling
(Elaine)
Jessica Galinas
(Rachel Bloomfield)
Kamilo Alonzo
(Kid Student)
Jesse Aponte
(Teacher)
Mariana Arevalo
(Party Guest)
Willy Bearden
(Family Member)
Renata Bresciani
(Secretary)
Jude Friedman
(Mason)
Robert DeAngelo
(Bar Mitzvah Guest)
Kinley Kingcade
(Kid Student)
Laurel Levey
(Hilda)
Stefano Kruger
(Church Parishioner)
Alexandra Astor
(Bar Mitzvah Guest)
Callie Herren
(Allie)