Love Finds You In Sugarcreek

Will a mysterious stranger's past wreak havoc on a quiet Amish community after they've opened their doors -- and hearts -- to him and his son?

Drama TV Movie Family Mystery

Tom Everett Scott

(Joe Matthews / Micah Matthias)

Sarah Lancaster

(Rachel Troyler)

Thomas Kapanowski

(Bobby Matthews / Bobby Matthias)

Kelly McGillis

(Bertha Troyler)

Nicole Badaan

(Kim)

Annie Kitral

(Lydia Troyler)

Katherine DeBoer

(Chloe Styles)

Marianna Alacchi

(Anna Troyler)

Ken Strunk

(Eli Troyler)

Greg Violand

(Ed Spencer)

John Eby

(Sam Phillips)

Geoffrey Hoffman

(Dylan Matthias)

Kaitlyn Sapp

(Elise)

Chris Van Vliet

(Reporter #1)

Jeannie Madison

(Reporter #2)

Madison Blake

(Ypung Rachel Troyler)

Dave McConnell

(Frank Troyer)

Joe Kurak

(Head Official)

Dave Durch

(Disheveled Guy)

Kyle Primous

(Mechanic)

Serena Miller

(Cashier)

Kris Leiter

(Umpire)

Mary Anne Prevost

(Mary Anne (Bank Teller))

Trenton Huff

(Bobby Double)

Abe M. Yoder

(Horse & Buggy Wrangler)

Nicole Miller

(Horse Trainer)

Blaze

(Buggy Horse)

Curtis Blackburn

(Amish Youths Chasing Buggy)

Jason Burroughs

(Amish Youths Chasing Buggy)

Ryan Schultz

(Grungy Guy)

Kirk Putman

(Garaway Baseball Team)

Michah VanFossen

(Garaway Baseball Team)

Brandon Weaver

(Garaway Baseball Team)

B.J. Schwartz

(Garaway Baseball Team)

Benjamin Mason

(Garaway Baseball Team)

Brandon Johnson

(Garaway Baseball Team)

Zach Huffman

(Garaway Baseball Team)

Tyrrell Keim

(Garaway Baseball Team)

Jerrod F. Hunt

(Garaway Baseball Team)

Joe Haynes

(Garaway Baseball Team)

Seth Miller

(Garaway Baseball Team)

Parker Barnhouse

(Garaway Baseball Team)