John Gallagher Jr.
(Johnny)
Michael Esper
(Will)
Matt Caplan
(Tunny)
Tony Vincent
(St. Jimmy)
Rebecca Naomi Jones
(Whatsername)
Mary Faber
(Heather)
Christina Sajous
(The Extraordinary Girl)
Joshua Henry
(The Favorite Son)
Theo Stockman
(Jingletown Representative / "Too Much Too Soon" Male Soloist)
Alysha Umphress
("Too Much Too Soon" Female Soloist)